Thursday, October 1, 2026

A Summary of Uthmân bin Affân’s Caliphate: Changes, Conquests, Unrest and the Conspiracy of Abdullah bin Saba

A Summary of Uthmân's Caliphate

Events of Uthmân bin Affân's tenure bring to view new phenomena we did not witness during the caliphates of Abu Bakr Siddiq and Umar Fâruq. Many things had changed beyond recognition. Up to the caliphate of Umar Fâruq, wealth and worldly possessions had no value. The Caliph was almost the poorest of all, no value was attached to worldly comforts neither by the ruler nor the ruled. The greatest desire of one and all was to lay down one's life in the way and for the Pleasure of Allâh the Almighty and uphold His Message. Such a desire and feeling lessened to a great extent. Uthmân bin Affân was a wealthy person and his way of life even after becoming Caliph showed signs thereof.

Countries and territories were conquered during the caliphate of Umar Fâruq bringing immense riches to the Muslims but they didn't get any worldly comforts from it. But the same wealth during the tenure of Uthmân bin Affân led them to develop love for a life of luxury. They were overpowered by the desire to purchase property and accumulate wealth. As a result of this, the characteristic spirit of vitality and military abilities decreased, which were once distinct signs of the Muslims and the Arabs. The thatched roofs began to change into palaces and palatial buildings. Military prowess gave way to rich habits. And this was the greatest misfortune that came to the Muslims.

Through the era of Abu Bakr Siddiq and Umar Fâruq the dominant force among the Muslims who had been in the company of the Prophet, was that they considered Islam a thing of their own and they had entrusted their lives to Islam. Islam had gained ground in their hearts so deeply that all tribal signs were wiped out. Nothing was dearer to them than Islam. The flood of conquests that engulfed vast territories, brought people to the fold of Islam in large numbers. Many witnessed the progress and prosperity of the Muslims and joined the cause with their own well-being in view. Islam had not come into their hearts to produce in them the sense of love and sacrifice for the new faith.

Most of victories during the tenure of Umar were the result of the battles won by the fighters from Banu Wâ'il, Banu Abdul-Qais, Banu Rabi'ah, Banu Azd, Banu Kindah, Banu Tamim, and Banu Quzâ'ah. It was they who had trampled under their feet Persian provinces, Syrian territories and the fertile lands of Egypt and Palestine. They alone had shattered the Persian and Roman Empires into pieces. But none of these tribes had ever drunk directly from the fountain of the Prophet. As a result, they were not on a par with the men of the Quraish and Hijâz in Faith and undying love for Islam. But Umar Fâruq had such vision that could see through all the problems and impediments in their depths and complexities and found solutions so skillfully that everyone was amazed. He had set up such a system and established such a leading role for the Muhâjirin and the Ansâr that up to his caliphate it remained impossible for elements outside this circle to even think of approaching this noble group. The position of the Muhâjirin and the Ansâr was, during his caliphate, like those of conquerors, yet men of wisdom.

Umar Fâruq had so prudently and cautiously preserved the characteristic military prowess and vitality of the Arab fighters that they were kept confined to settlements away from the lust and attraction of the Syrian cities. He, on the other hand, kept distinguished Companions and those in commanding positions away from the company of the masses and ordinary classes.

He did this so wisely and imperceptibly that nobody was aware of it and he managed their affairs in a manner that their awe and dread could not be eroded from the minds of their subordinates. And, above all, a party of the elite and men wielding power, influence and prudence always remained clustered around him in Al-Madinah.

But, during the caliphate of Uthmân bin Affân such practices gradually disappeared. Arab tribes began to consider themselves equal to the Muhâjirin and the Ansâr and even superior to them. The Companions who commanded dignity were scattered in far off places, with the result that the commanding force of Al-Madinah was weakened beyond description, and confusion and disorder became common. Thus the capital of Islam could not longer remain the center of power. In such a state of crisis, old tribal rivalries and feuds strongly emerged and Islamic brotherhood could not contain them. The new entrants outnumbered the Muhâjirin and the Ansâr, and took away from them the reins of power and influence.

Uthmân bin Affân was polite to the extreme. But softness alone is not helpful in running an administration; it needs the manifestation of power and strong actions at times. During the caliphate of Uthmân bin Affân, the Muslims indulged in a life of luxuries and comforts on one hand and the dread and awe of the Caliph had eroded on the other. In such an untenable situation, ambitions and power hungry sections got ample opportunity to give vent to their desire of holding power. Thus such men of ambition among the Quraish and Hijâz could easily win the help and support of the new-Muslim tribes and fighters.

The Quraish tribe before Islam was understood to be divided into two parts, Banu Umayyah and Banu Hâshim. Even though these two tribes alone did not make up the entire Quraish and other tribes were also important. But since these two tribes were opposed to one another, other tribes were attached to either of the two. The power and influence of Banu Umayyah had surpassed Banu Hâshim at the time of advent of Islam. As a natural corollary, Banu Umayyah was vehemently opposed to the Prophethood for Muhammad belonged to Banu Hâshim. Abu Sufyân hailed from Banu Umayyah and was so dedicated to the defeat of Islam that he led the disbelievers against Islam in the battles of Uhud and the Confederates. But, at last Banu Umayyah including Abu Sufyân confessed Islam. Thus the differences and rivalries between Banu Hâshim and Banu Umayyah came to an end. Islam obliterated all signs and traces of racial and tribal distinctions.

While Abu Bakr Siddiq and Umar Fâruq held the rein of caliphate, the state of affairs went undisturbed. But during the caliphate of Uthmân bin Affân, old rivalries staged a comeback. And since Uthmân bin Affân was from Banu Umayyah, and he held his relatives very dear, they took undue advantage of that.

Besides these new developments, which took place due to the weak caliphate, new entrants to the fold of Islam, the erosion of power and influence of the Muhâjirin, Ansâr and the Quraish, mass indulgence in the life of luxuries were some of the factors that proved advantageous to Banu Umayyah. Marwân bin Al-Hakam as the main scribe of the Caliph, benefited their cause immensely. When the governorship of a number of provinces came to their possession, and they were able to wield power and influence throughout, they set off to restore their position prior to Islam.

Gradually Banu Hâshim and others also grew conscious of the prevailing situation. But to say that Uthmân bin Affân was a party to Banu Umayyah's policies and programs is far from reality and is a baseless charge.

Nevertheless, the polite behavior and softness towards relatives played a significant role in encouraging Banu Umayyah to cross all limits. And they did what could not be conceived of during the tenures of the former Caliphs. But, one is however, compelled to say that, although good treatment to relatives is quite reasonable, a Caliph must walk very cautiously upon this track. But he, perhaps, failed to see these reasons. Marwân bin Al-Hakam, his cousin did all what he could to deteriorate the situation but Uthmân bin Affân did nothing to get rid of him, particularly when Marwân did not deserve such an important post by virtue of his abilities and character.

With Uthmân bin Affân at the helm, Persian provinces began to rise in revolt. But Islamic forces also rose to punish the insurgents. The control and conquest of Seistân and Kirmân are examples of this. Besides, Harât, Kâbul, Balkh and some other territories were conquered in the wake of Turkish and Chinese invasions. Muslim armies won Cyprus and Rhodes as a result of the Roman assaults on Egypt and Alexandria. Because of the war preparations of the Romans of Africa and Asia Minor, Muslim territories extended to Tripoli and Armenia.

In short, many important victories were won during the caliphate of Uthmân bin Affân also. Following the instructions of Uthmân bin Affân, the governors constructed roads, set up educational institutions and promoted trading and agricultural development. But one cannot afford to overlook the undeniable fact that all such progress and developmental works took place during the first half of his caliphate, while disturbances and disruptions marked the next half. The Muslims who were devoted to the task of preaching Islam and uprooting idolatry, now worked for vested interests and engaged in rivalries and feuds of the worst nature. Banu Umayyah had, by now, multiplied their strength and influence and succeeded in expanding their areas of domination far and wide.

It was, nevertheless, necessary for other Muslim tribes to vie with Banu Umayyah in their activities injurious to Islamic unity and solidarity. The sober and saner section among the Muhâjirin and Ansâr could have come to the rescue but, unfortunately it did not happen. Meanwhile, the wretched Jew, Abdullah bin Saba dominated the disruptive scene and caused such damage to the Muslims that they have never completely recovered.

Even during the Prophetic era, the Muslim Ummah had suffered at the hands of the hypocrites led by Abdullah bin Ubai, while under the leadership of Abdullah bin Saba, they inflicted an irreparable loss. Abdullah bin Ubai could not make any headway because of the presence of the Prophet, but Abdullah bin Saba had no one to combat his nefarious activities effectively.

To oppose Banu Umayyah, he used Ali (رَضِيَ ٱللَّٰهُ عَنْهُ) and easily antagonized almost all tribes of Arabia against them. These were all those who took pride in their deeds of valor and looked down upon the Quraish and the men of the Hijâz. However, they were not among the first entrants to Islam and were known as new-Muslims. Abdullah bin Saba did not experience much difficulty in rousing the people against Uthmân bin Affân. He roamed through Basrah, Kufah and Damascus and visited military cantonments. He found favorable situations everywhere except in Damascus. He used the dispute between Abu Dhar Ghifâri and Mu’âwiyah (رَضِيَ ٱللَّٰهُ عَنْهُ) for his purpose. At the end of his travels he reached Egypt and began to give shape to his plans from there. Abdullah bin Saad, the governor of Egypt was ahead of all in self-will and freedom of action but deficient in farsightedness and prudence, and careless about internal peace and the welfare of the people. Abdullah bin Saba found here two or three of the Companions who supported his cause.

He noticed that although Talhah had more influence in Basrah and Zubair in Kufah, the whole world of Islam was still under the influence of Ali. Thus he sat down in Egypt to organize and consolidate his camp so cleverly that the people of Kufah and Basrah could be easily aroused against Banu Umayyah and Uthmân bin Affân. In Egypt, he gave publicity to his love for Ali, his victimization, his right of the caliphate and his being the sole executor after the Prophet. He did everything so cautiously and cleverly that in a very short time, a party of Ali's supporters was formed. Very soon the entire world of Islam was carried away by disruptions. Thus the Companions lost the chance to bring Banu Umayyah back to the right path.

The worst kind of mischief caused by Abdullah bin Saba was a large number of letters to the people of Kufah, Basrah and Egypt on behalf of Ali (رَضِيَ ٱللَّٰهُ عَنْهُ) from Al-Madinah. These letters played a vital role in winning the easily excited people to his side. His plan had two purposes, Uthmân was to be assassinated on one hand and the finger of suspicion was to be pointed towards Ali, and alas, this baseless doubt lingers on to this day. Abdullah bin Saba was friend neither of Uthmân nor Ali; he was an enemy of both and his sole aim was to destroy Islam. He, thus, got Uthmân on one hand and caused immense harm to the reputation of Ali (رَضِيَ ٱللَّٰهُ عَنْهُ) on the other.

No comments:

Post a Comment