Sunday, November 1, 2026

The Character, Personal Qualities, and Leadership of Caliph Mamoon Rasheed

Nature and Habits

In respect to prudence, determination, tolerance, scholarship and valor Caliph Mamoon Rasheed was superior to all amongst the Banu Abbas dynasty. He used to say, "Amir Muawiya needed Amr bin Aas and Abdul Malik needed Hajjaj but I needed no one." He had a predilection to the Shiite way; he felt that the Alawiites deserved respect and the Caliphate more than all others. That was why he removed his brother Motamin and made Ali Raza his successor and had his daughter married to him. He had a mind to vacate his Caliphate and install him as Caliph in his own presence. However, after the passage of ten years and during the last period of his Caliphate he changed his mind following the betrayal and rebellion of the Alawiites. He also wanted to issue instructions that none should remember Amir Muawiya with respect and he should be declared a wrong doer but he did not do so at the instance of the people.

He was also very fond of reading the Quran. During some Ramadan, he finished the Quran once everyday. When he made Ali Raza his heir-apparent, a few from among Banu Abbas said to him, "Please don't hand over the Caliphate to the Alawites." Mamoon said, "During his regime Ali bin Abi Talib had deputed Banu Abbas to govern most of the provinces. I want to reciprocate and give power and the Caliphate to their descendants."

When Mamoon provided an opportunity to the followers of all faiths and religions to give vent to their opinions openly at Darul Munazirah, the institution that he created to allow free exchange of thought, academic discussions began to take place in an unrestrained way. Hair splitting and sophistic techniques more dedicated to debate than the seeking of truth evolved. The points of debate, which had little to do with the science of the religion, produced antagonistic parties over frivolous philosophies. Mamoon was drawn into these debates and became a participant in this competition. These unrestrained religious debates resulted in the creation of unnecessary and insignificant problems. There was a debate about the creation of the Quran. Mamoon was convinced by the school of thought that maintained that the Quran was created and he began to perpetrate atrocities on those who did not agree with him. The consequence of that pressure and oppression was disastrous. The scholars of the opposite points of view began to oppose him more vehemently and that generated even more rigid antagonism and prejudice to the extent that even after his death some scholars of Islam have been greatly agonized on account of this unreal and unnecessary problem.

Abu Muhammad Yazidi says that he used to teach Mamoon in his childhood. Once the servants complained to him saying, "When you go away, he beats the servants and behaves wantonly with them." Yazidi struck him with his stick seven times. Mamoon was weeping and wiping his eyes when the Prime Minister Jafar Barmuk appeared while Yazidi left. Jafar talked to Mamoon until he laughed and then left. Yazidi came back to him and said, "I was fearing that you would complain to Jafar." Mamoon said, "Leave Jafar I can not complain to my father for you had beaten me for my benefit." Yahya bin Aksam says: "One day I was sleeping in Mamoon Rasheed's room, Mamoon was also asleep. He awakened me saying, 'Please see if there is something near my feet?' I looked but found nothing but he was not satisfied. He called the servants. They lighted a lamp and saw that a snake was sitting under his bed. I said to him, 'you possess the knowledge of the unseen along with your other merits.' He said I seek refuge in Allah! What are you saying? The fact is that I just had a dream in which somebody warned me against the danger of a naked sword. I at once woke up and I felt that some ugly incident would take place very soon. The bed was the nearest thing. So I looked into it and the snake was found."

Mohammad bin Mansoor says: "Mamoon used to say that 'a noble man is he who bears the atrocities perpetrated against him by his superior and does not persecute him who is inferior to him.'" Sayeed bin Muslim says: "Mamoon once said, 'If the criminals come to know how much I love forgiveness, their fear will vanish and their hearts will be filled with joy.'"

Mamoon said to a criminal, "By Allah, I shall slay you." He said, "Please be tolerant for softness is half of forgiveness." Mamoon said, "Now I have sworn an oath." He said, "If you go to Allah as a violator of an oath, it is better than to go to Him as a killer." Mamoon forgave him. Abdus Salam bin Salah says: "One day I was sleeping in Mamoon's room. The lamp was going out. He found that his servant was asleep. Mamoon left the bed, set the wick right and went back to sleep." In another incident Mamoon would say, "Often it happens that I am in the bathroom and the servants abuse and accuse me. They think that I have not heard them but I hear and forgive them and never let them know that I have heard them."

One day Mamoon was sailing in a boat on the Tigris River. There was a curtain hanging separating the compartments on the boat. On the opposite side were sitting some sailors who did not know that Mamoon was there. One of them said, "Mamoon must be thinking that I have love and honor for him in my heart but he does not understand that I have no love and honor left in my heart for a man who had his own brother killed." Mamoon began to smile and said, "Friends! Tell me how I can endear myself to this great man."

Yahya bin Aksam says, "I was sleeping in Mamoon's room. I was about to fall asleep when Mamoon wanted to cough. He stuffed his mouth with the lower part of his shirt to prevent making a disturbance for the other sleepers." He used to say, "To me the domination of an argument appears to be better than the domination of nature or power for the latter will vanish with the passing away of nature or power and the former never meets its end." He used to say, "Love of flattery is bad for a king. Worse is a judge's narrow heartedness, which precedes the comprehension of the issue concerned. Still worse is the lack of wisdom on the part of the legal scholars in the matters of religion. Worse still is the miserliness of the rich, making fun of the elders, laziness of the youth and display of cowardice on the battlefield."

Ali bin Abdur Raheem Marwrozi says, "Mamoon used to say, 'The man is an enemy to his own self who wants the nearness of the person who likes to be away from him, honors the man who does not respect him and feels delighted at the praise of a man whom he does not know.'"

Hudba bin Khalid says, "One day I was partaking of a meal with Mamoon. When the tablecloth was removed, I began to pick up the small pieces of food that had fallen on the floor and eat them. Mamoon said, 'Are you still hungry?' I said, 'I have had my fill but a Hadith says that one who eats the fallen bits of food after the removal of the tablecloth will never be poor.' He then gave me 1000 dinars."

Once Haroon Rasheed visited Kufa after Hajj and requested the presence of the scholars of Hadith from there. All of them came except Abdullah bin Idris and Isa bin Yunus who refused to come. Haroon Rasheed sent his two sons Ameen and Mamoon. When they went to Abdullah bin Idris, he addressed Ameen and narrated a hundred Hadiths to him. Mamoon was sitting and listening. When he stopped narrating, Mamoon said, "If you permit me, I can narrate all those Hadith." He granted permission and Mamoon narrated all the Hadiths quite correctly.

Ibn Idris was stunned by Mamoon's sharp memory. He said, "I was never stunned into silence by the reply of a person except once by the inhabitants of Kufa. They came and complained against the governor of Kufa. I said, 'You lie that governor is very just.' They said, 'Undoubtedly we are liars and Amir al-Muminin is truthful. But why has our city alone been selected and reserved for his justice. Please send him to some other city so that, another city should also be benefited from his justice as our city has been benefited.' I had to say under compulsion, 'Well then, go. I have dismissed him.'"

Yahya bin Aktham states, "One night I was sleeping in Mamoon's room, I felt thirst in middle of the night. I grew restless and began to turn from one side to the other. Mamoon asked me the reason. I said, 'I am thirsty.' He left his bed, brought water and made me drink it. I said, 'Why didn't you call a servant?' He said, 'My father heard from his father and he heard from his grandfather and he heard from Uqba bin Amir, that the Prophet said, 'The leader of the people is their servant.'"

The most praiseworthy and remarkable thing about the acts and achievements of Caliph Mamoon Rasheed is the fact that while nominating his successor he gave proof of his good intention and great courage and was not trapped by his paternal affection as the Caliphs before him who continued the injustice of choosing their sons as their successor and thereby strengthened the curse of hereditary rule on the Islamic Caliphate.

By nominating Imam Ali Raza as his heir-apparent and depriving the dynasty of the Abbasids he acted freely, selected the best man for the job in the way adopted by Abu Bakr in making Umar bin Khattab his successor. However, Mamoon came to know very soon that the Abbasids would not accept it willingly and it would lead the Islamic world into trouble by creating disorder and riots. Imam Ali Raza's death nipped Mamoon's wishes in bud. Then he selected his own brother Abu Ishaq Motasim as his successor and deprived his own son Abbas of the throne despite the latter's ability to run the administration and the Caliphate. Since Motasim was more capable than Abbas in administrative affairs, he selected Motasim and did not prefer his son. Mamoon's predecessors had continuously committed the fault of fixing two successors in place of one. Had he followed them, he would have nominated his own son Abbas and been satisfied that his son would be Caliph after Motasim but he disliked and rejected this act that had no Islamic precedent. He is admired for many things but for this deed, he is not appreciated as much as he deserves.

No comments:

Post a Comment