Friday, October 2, 2026

The Battle of Karbala: Imam Husain’s Final Negotiations and the Eve of Martyrdom

The Disaster at Karbala

Obaidullah bin Zeyad named Amr bin Sa'd bin Abi Waqas the governor of Rayy and gave him four thousand soldiers to keep watch on all paths and roads into Kufa and to find out by which route Husain bin Ali رضي الله عنه was coming and where was he camping. He also gave Hur bin Yazid Tamimi one thousand soldiers and put him on patrol. Amr bin Sa'd started collecting information of different sources while he was camped at Qadisiya. Husain bin Ali رضي الله عنه was in a dilemma and in that state, he reached Saraf. When he moved forward, Hur blocked him with his one thousand soldiers. Imam Husain رضي الله عنه went forward and said to him, "I have come here at your call. If you stick to your pledge, I will enter the city otherwise I shall go the way by which I have come." Hur said, "I have been ordered by Obaidullah bin Zeyad to stay with you and take you to him in our custody." Husain رضي الله عنه said, "It is impossible to bear the humiliation of going to him in custody." He then wanted to go back. Hur, out of fear of Ibn Zeyad, wanted to stop him and stood with his army on the way of his retreat. Imam Husain رضي الله عنه moved to north and reached Qadisiya. He became aware that Amr bin Sa'd, along with a large army, was camping there. Hur followed Husain bin Ali رضي الله عنه. Following this discovery, Imam Husain رضي الله عنه left Qadisiya and after covering ten miles halted at Karbala. Amr bin Sa'd was informed of his arrival and set out with his army and following him arrived at Karbala. After camping in same vicinity Amr bin Sa'd left his army and came toward Imam Husain's camp and called for him. After exchanging greetings, Ibn Sa'd said,

"Undoubtedly, you deserve the caliphate more than Yazid does but it is not the intention of Allah to let both prophethood and caliphate come into your family. You have seen the circumstances and conditions of Ali bin Abi Talib رضي الله عنه and Hasan bin Ali رضي الله عنه. If you give up the thought of this sultanate and rule, you can easily become free otherwise your life will be in jeopardy and we have been ordered to arrest you."

Imam Husain رضي الله عنه said,

"I put three alternatives before you, you may choose any of them for me.

1.     Let me go the way I came so that I may remain absorbed in prayer in Makkah.

2.     Let me move to any border so that I may be martyred while fighting with the unbelievers.

3.     Leave my way free and let me go to Yazid in Damascus. For your satisfaction, you may follow me. I shall go to Yazid and settle my affairs directly with him as my elder brother Imam Hasan رضي الله عنه did with Amir Muawiya."

Amr bin Sa'd was very pleased to hear what he said and replied that he was not in a position to give him the final reply in this matter. He further said that he would inform Obaidullah bin Zeyad at once, and he was sure that he would agree to any of the three points. Amr bin Sa'd was camped on the same plain he wrote to Ibn Zeyad a detailed account of the meeting, this took place on Muharram 2, 61 A.H. Obaidullah bin Zeyad was overjoyed reading Amr bin Sa'd's letter. He said, "Imam Husain رضي الله عنه has spoken in a way that will put a stop to all evil disorders and by going to Yazid he will take ba'it (the oath of allegiance), and then there will be no longer any danger." Shimr Dhul Jaushan was present there at the time. He said, "O Amir! You have an opportunity now. You may kill the Imam without hesitation. No one will blame you. However, if he goes to Yazid, you will no longer be honored and respected in comparison to him and he will be able to enjoy a greater status than you." When Ibn Zeyad heard this, he wrote to Amr bin Sa'd.

"All these three alternatives cannot be accepted. The one thing acceptable is: let Imam Husain رضي الله عنه surrender before me and take the oath of allegiance for Yazid at my hands as his deputy and then I shall send him to Yazid on my own."

On the receipt of this reply, Amr bin Sa'd informed Imam Husain رضي الله عنه that he was helpless and said that Ibn Zeyad first wanted ba'it at his hands and did not agree to any other proposal. Imam Husain رضي الله عنه replied that it was better for him to die than take bay'at on Ibn Zeyad's hand.

Ibn Sa'd was trying his best to avoid bloodshed. He wanted that either Imam Husain رضي الله عنه should accept Ibn Zeyad's conditions or Ibn Zeyad should let him go according to his wish. During the week long correspondences of refusal and insistence both Imam Husain رضي الله عنه and Ibn Sa'd along with their men, remained camped on the field of Karbala. Imam Husain's men made their prayers with Ibn Sa'd's soldiers and Imam Husain رضي الله عنه used to straighten the Saf (the rows of those praying). When Ibn Zeyad was informed of this, he became worried Ibn Sa'd might conspire with Imam Husain رضي الله عنه. He at once called in a herald named Jowira bin Tamimi and gave him a letter for Ibn Sa'd:

"I ordered you to arrest Husain bin Ali رضي الله عنه. It was your duty to have arrested him and brought him to me. If you were unable to do so, you should have brought his head to me. I did not order you to join his company and promote friendly relations with him. Now it is better for you that immediately after reading this letter and without any hesitation either bring Husain bin Ali رضي الله عنه to me or fight with him, cut off his head and send it to me. If you hesitate even a little, then the bearer of this letter, who is a military officer, has been ordered to arrest you and bring you to me while the army should remain camped there and wait for the next commander whom I shall send in your place."

Taking the letter Jowira reached Ibn Sa'd on Thursday Muharram 9, 61 A.H. Ibn Sa'd was sitting in his camp at that time. As soon as he read the letter, he stood up, mounted on his horse and ordered his army to get ready and said to Jowira, "Bear witness that as soon as I have read the Amir's order, I have complied with it." Then he set the rows of soldiers and taking Jowira along moved forward. He sent for Imam Husain رضي الله عنه and acquainted him with the contents of the letter and the herald. Imam Husain رضي الله عنه asked him to grant one days' time. Ibn Sa'd looked towards Jowira who said that the next day was not far and that he should be granted the time. Ibn Sa'd returned from the field and ordered the soldiers to relax because there would not be any fighting on that day.

After sending his order through Jowira, Obaidullah bin Zeyad thought that if Ibn Sa'd showed slackness and Jowira made him captive the army would become bewildered and scattered without their commander and just possibly they might join Imam Husain رضي الله عنه. In that case, it would be very a difficult situation and Imam Husain رضي الله عنه would have time to escape to Makkah and get out of their reach. He at once called Shimr Dhul Jaushan to him and said I have sent Jowira with the order that if Ibn Sa'd hesitated, he should be arrested and brought to me. I suspect him to be a hypocrite. If Jowira arrests Ibn Sa'd, the army will be in the field without a leader and may falter and be lost. I can't find anybody else better than you for this task. Go to Karbala and if Ibn Sa'd is arrested, take command of the army, fight with Imam Husain رضي الله عنه and cut of his head and bring it to me. If Ibn Sa'd is not arrested and is hesitant in fighting, go and start it and finish the work at once." Shimr said to him, "I have a condition. You know that my sister Umm Lambeen bint Haram was Ali's wife who bore him four sons named Obaidullah, Jafar, Uthman, and Abbas. They are present on the plain of Karbala along with their brother Husain رضي الله عنه. Give me protection for their lives." Obaidullah bin Zeyad at once had a paper brought to him and wrote Aman — pardon and safety, sealed it and gave it to Shimr and sent him off.

Jowira left at night and early on Thursday morning reached the army at Karbala. Shimr left in the morning and reached at Asr time (late afternoon). He briefed him with all that occurred. Shimr said, "I would not have granted him even a single moment. Either get ready at once or hand over the army to me." Ibn Sa'd sat on the horse and taking Shimr with him, went to Imam Husain رضي الله عنه and told him that Obaidullah bin Zeyad had sent another messenger and that he was not ready to grant him any delay in the battle. Imam Husain رضي الله عنه said, "Subhan Allah, What is the necessity of granting me time now? The sun is setting. Won't you defer the fight to tomorrow?" Hearing that Shimr thought it proper to wait until the next morning and both returned to their camps.

No comments:

Post a Comment