Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Islamic Caliphate: Divine Authority, Righteous Rule and the Succession of Leadership

Claim to Caliphate

From the Quran it becomes clear beyond doubt that rule or caliphate on earth is from Allâh and He Alone can take it back.

It is said:

"O Allâh! Possessor of the kingdom, You give the kingdom to whom You will, and You take the kingdom from whom You will." (3:26)

Now it is to be seen as to who really deserves the caliphate or rule, and what are the distinctive signs of those who are given caliphate. According to the Quran, it is knowledge on which the rule over mankind is based.

"And He taught Adam all the names (of everything)." (2:31)

While the angels considered the traits of corruption and disruption against a righteous caliphate, and the mention and glorification of Allâh the Almighty to be the consideration for making one deserve the caliphate. We have seen clearly that human beings established their rule over other creatures due to their power of knowledge only. Had man not been adorned and strengthened with deep and wide knowledge, even a gust of wind, a wave of water, a leaf of some tree or a particle of dust could have rendered him helpless. It is by virtue of his knowledge that even a lion, an elephant, river, mountain, wind, fire, and lightening are at his service and are ready to obey him and comfort him like his servants. The Quran informs us when there were objections to the kingship of Tâlut (Saul), Allâh the Almighty answered the detractors through His Prophet:

"Verily Allâh has chosen him above you and has increased him abundantly in knowledge and stature. And Allâh grants His kingdom to whom He wills." (2:247)

Having conferred rule and caliphate on Dâwud (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), Allâh the Almighty commanded

"So judge you between men in truth and follow not your desire." (38:26)

In another Verse, He said:

"And indeed We destroyed generations before you when they did wrong, while their Messengers came to them with clear proofs, but they were not such as to believe! That do We requite the people who are sinners. Then We made you successors after them, generations after generations in the land that We might see how you would work." (10:13,14)

Hundreds of Verses from the Quran may be produced to establish that caliph stands for 'ruler' and caliphate for 'rule'. And in order to rule establishing knowledge, justice, reform, power and welfare of mankind are some of the prerequisite conditions, which have always been required from a king or ruler without which he cannot keep his rule intact. All these good qualities can only be obtained through the teachings of the Prophets and the Messengers of Allâh. However, it is also necessary that a Prophet has to be a ruler in order to set the example. Had mere prayers and glorification of Allâh the Almighty been enough, only Prophets or angels would have ruled the world. In short, the caliphate is another name for the rule which Allâh the Almighty confers on those He wants. However, when a ruling nation indulges in corruption and wrongdoing, Allâh the Almighty takes it away from them.

Islamic Caliphate

All the progress made by mankind so far along with all his academic and moral virtues are the outcome of the teachings of the Prophets. Prophets have sometimes came as teachers, for instance, like Isa (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) (Jesus Christ), and at times as monarchs like Dâwud (David) (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). The religious codes brought by monarch-Prophets are more perfect and magnificent than those of the teacher-Prophets. The teacher-Prophets set examples for every member of their Ummah (community) while the monarch-Prophets not only set examples but have the power to enforce codes and make the people follow them. When the teacher-Prophet departs from the world after finishing his task, none can succeed him in matters of Prophethood, for the Prophet receives Revelation from Allâh the Almighty to convey to his people.

Now as a matter of general principle, the successor of a Prophet must be a Prophet. But since a Prophet departs from the world only after completing the task assigned to him, he needs no successor after him. This is why no teacher-Prophet has ever had a successor. However, as far as a monarch-Prophet is concerned, nobody can succeed him as a Prophet but his rule may be succeed by anybody as a successor. Since the successor would have been brought up under the shadow of the Prophet's teachings, he is supposed to be the most suitable person to do the job. Since Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) was the perfect and the last Prophet and had been sent with the complete guidelines, he was, therefore, a ruling-Prophet and his rule is the best and most perfect example for rulers and leaders to the Day of Judgment.

He was essentially supposed to have a successor or caliph after him, and there actually have been many who have succeeded him in temporal affairs. In addition, there were those among them who were brought up in the mould of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) and had the stamp of Prophetic character and adopted the pattern of his Prophetic rule. Their rule came to be called the Rightly-Guided Caliphate. But the farther they happened to be from the days of Prophetic rule, their caliphate showed a difference from that of the primary example.

Objection to the Procedure of electing a Caliph

After the time of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), some people among the Muslims raised doubts of a ridiculous nature regarding the procedure adopted for electing a caliph. But, in truth, all such charges are false and fabricated for the choice of a ruler or caliph rests wholly and solely with Allâh the Almighty. He Alone gives it to someone and takes it away from others. He never left this job to any human.

The Quran delineates the task of a caliph and its dos and don'ts. It gives detailed guidance about the prayer, fasting, Hajj, Zakât, the rights of Allâh and His servants but doesn't mention the succession of the Prophet. This is because He gives it to the one He chooses for the job and makes arrangements for this. Allâh the Almighty Alone knows who deserves the job. The one who succeeded the first caliph was the one whom Allâh chose for the job. If any other person is brought forward as the most deserving for the post, in fact, it is to say that Allâh the Almighty failed to bring a man of His choice for the post. It means He (Allâh forbid) was defeated in His Plan.

Thus to raise a dispute in this matter is tantamount to objecting to the choice of the Almighty. Thus, the detractors of Abu Bakr's caliphate are like those who object to the decision of a judge in a court of law, the judge cannot alter his judgment because of their deprecation. Now if anybody disapproves of the caliphate of a person, in fact, he stands against the Judgment of Allâh the Exalted and Most High.

No comments:

Post a Comment